Reflections on Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics – Friendship and Virtue

Inspired by Fr. Robert Barron – Word on Fire Show, Episode 300

Aristotle’s concept of friendship, as explored in Book 8 of his Nicomachean Ethics, offers profound insights into human relationships. He famously asserts, “A friend is a second self.” This idea suggests that genuine friendship is deeply intertwined with virtue, truth, and human flourishing. Good friendships act as a matrix from which the attainment of truth and moral goodness arise. Authentic friendship is vital for our personal growth, as it nurtures both virtue and moral goodness in each individual.

The Role of Friendship in Virtue
At its core, Aristotle argues that friendship is not just a social bond, but a commitment to virtue. We form friendships with those whose virtues we admire and wish to embody ourselves. A true friend is someone who helps us grow, challenges our assumptions, and encourages our moral and intellectual development. It is in this space of mutual dedication to goodness that a "second self" arises — a companion who not only mirrors our best qualities but also inspires us toward greater heights.

The Three Types of Friendship
Aristotle categorizes friendships into three types:
1. Friendship of Pleasure
- This form of friendship arises from shared enjoyment or good feelings.
- These friendships are often fleeting, formed around common activities or pleasures.
- The value of the friend is not based on their character, but rather on the joy they provide.

2. Friendship of Utility
- These friendships are based on mutual benefit, often arising in professional or practical contexts.
- For example, a colleague at work or a service provider like a mechanic.
- These relationships exist primarily for practical reasons, and their depth is limited.

3. Friendship of Virtue
- This is the highest form of friendship, where friends love one another for their intrinsic goodness.
- These friendships go beyond mere pleasure or utility; they are rooted in shared values and a mutual desire to grow in virtue.
- Friends rejoice in each other’s successes and strive together toward personal and moral excellence.
- This type of friendship requires time, effort, and sacrifice—qualities that make it rare and deeply meaningful.

As I reflect on these concepts, I find myself drawn to two key questions to ponder,
1. Do we look for friends who are different from us? What kinds of diversities are important in friendships?
Friendship does not always thrive in homogeneous environments. In places like workplaces, faith communities, schools, or volunteer organizations, we often encounter people who differ greatly in terms of personal backgrounds, interests, values, and life experiences.
These differences, whether cultural, socio-economic, political, or even neurodiverse, can lead to rich learning opportunities. Engaging with diverse perspectives can challenge our assumptions, deepen our empathy, and refine our social and moral intelligence. By interacting with those from different walks of life, we grow not only in our understanding of others but also in our own capacity for compassion and creativity.

2. What factors influence the transition of friendships from one type to another?
Friendships are dynamic, shifting over time as individuals change and grow. Life events, personal development, shared experiences, and evolving values all play a role in how friendships evolve. But perhaps the most profound question is: How many friendships reach the level of a Friendship of Virtue?
Aristotle himself acknowledges that these friendships are rare, as they require sustained effort, deep commitment, and a willingness to sacrifice for one another. This is a friendship where the truth of who we are emerges through dialogue, mutual support, and the shared pursuit of goodness.

I thought through the people in my lives and indeed I am blessed.

Aristotle’s exploration of friendship in the Nicomachean Ethics invites us to reflect on the nature of our own relationships. Friendship, in its highest form, is a partnership in the pursuit of virtue and truth. As we navigate the complexities of life and the various friendships we form, it is important to recognize the potential for growth and transformation that comes from authentic, virtuous friendships. These are the relationships that not only shape our character but ultimately lead us to a fuller, more flourishing life.

Read:
Philosophy through Humour in "Plato and a Platypus Walk into a Bar
The Ones who care
The 9 Characteristics of Genuine Fellowship
Confucius Says... Education is the key to making people humane
Knowledge vs. Wisdom
Lessons learnt from "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button"
Applying Sun Tzu's Art of War
Knowledge is Power. Content is King
The Last Lecture by Randy Pausch
Being in Flow - Leading to Happiness
Come away and not think for awhile...
Learning from the Wrongologist - Kathryn Schulz